When it comes to the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU), surprises are part of the game. With new films and crossovers constantly in the works, even the most loyal fans find themselves guessing what might happen next. One of the biggest ongoing mysteries in the superhero world right now? Whether Andrew Garfield will return as Spider-Man in the upcoming Avengers movies — Doomsday and Secret Wars.
And true to form, Garfield’s recent comments about the possibility have sent fans into a frenzy — not because of what he said, but how he said it.
Andrew Garfield’s Trademark Evasive Answer
During a recent interview with MTV, the Tick, Tick… Boom! and The Amazing Spider-Man star was asked point-blank whether he’ll be reprising his role as Peter Parker in Avengers: Secret Wars. His response? A perfect blend of humor and mystery.
He laughed and replied:
“You’ll find out! Whatever response I’m having, is it exasperation? Is it? I don’t know. You’ll find out.”
Garfield’s awkward laughter and evasive phrasing immediately reminded fans of how he handled similar questions before the release of Spider-Man: No Way Home. At the time, he repeatedly denied being in the movie — even going as far as to say “it’s not happening” — only to later appear in one of the most exciting cinematic surprises in recent memory.
Now, fans are wondering: is Garfield lying again, or is this just playful trolling?
The Legacy of Lying: Andrew Garfield and No Way Home
When Spider-Man: No Way Home released in 2021, it wasn’t just another superhero film — it became a cultural phenomenon. The reunion of three generations of Spider-Men — Tobey Maguire, Andrew Garfield, and Tom Holland — was one of the most emotional and fan-pleasing moments in MCU history.
However, in the months leading up to the release, Garfield maintained an elaborate web of denial. He insisted countless times that he wasn’t part of the movie, even though leaks and rumors strongly suggested otherwise. By the time fans finally saw him swing back into action on the big screen, his “lies” had turned into one of Hollywood’s most amusing PR legends.
So now, whenever Garfield gets asked about returning as Spider-Man, fans immediately raise an eyebrow — because let’s face it, after No Way Home, no one’s taking his word at face value again.
The Future of the Spider-Verse in the MCU
Marvel’s upcoming lineup includes two major crossover films — Avengers: Doomsday (set to release on December 18, 2026) and Avengers: Secret Wars (releasing on December 17, 2027).
While Marvel Studios is keeping plot details under lock and key, many fans believe Secret Wars will be a multiversal event, drawing heroes and villains from across different universes. In the comic storyline, Secret Wars sees characters from multiple realities brought together to fight in a massive, reality-bending conflict — and that opens the door for characters like Tobey Maguire’s and Andrew Garfield’s Spider-Men to reappear.
Given that No Way Home already confirmed the existence of multiple Spider-Men in the MCU, the stage is perfectly set for their return.
Why Fans Want Garfield Back
Among all the Spider-Men, Andrew Garfield’s version of Peter Parker holds a special place in fans’ hearts. His portrayal combined youthful charm with deep emotional weight, especially in The Amazing Spider-Man 2, where audiences watched his character face heartbreak and loss.
When he returned in No Way Home, it was clear that his story still had unfinished business. Fans loved seeing Garfield’s Spider-Man get a moment of redemption — particularly when he saved Zendaya’s MJ, a direct callback to his tragic failure with Gwen Stacy (played by Emma Stone).
Ever since then, audiences have been campaigning for more. The hashtags #MakeTASM3 and #BringBackAndrewGarfield have trended multiple times, as fans express their desire to see him don the suit once again — either in a solo sequel or a multiverse crossover.
The Multiverse Door is Still Open
At the end of No Way Home, Garfield and Maguire’s Spider-Men were shown returning to their own universes, leaving Tom Holland’s Peter Parker behind. However, thanks to Doctor Strange’s spell, it’s implied that only they — and no one else — remember that version of Peter.
This intriguing detail has fans theorizing that Marvel intentionally left the door open for future appearances. In a multiverse-driven saga like Secret Wars, it wouldn’t be surprising to see them reappear as allies in an epic final battle — or even as alternate versions of Spider-Man with key roles in saving the universe.
Whether it’s just a cameo, a major role, or even another crossover scene with Holland, Garfield’s Peter Parker still feels relevant to Marvel’s grander multiverse story.
Andrew Garfield’s Next Moves
Outside of the Spider-Man buzz, Garfield continues to impress with a diverse acting career. From his Academy Award-nominated performance in Tick, Tick… Boom! to roles in dramatic films and series, he’s shown remarkable range.
Still, no matter how many awards he wins or genres he explores, fans always circle back to his Spider-Man. The MCU’s multiverse offers him the unique chance to revisit that character while still pursuing creative projects outside the superhero genre.
And if Garfield does appear in Secret Wars, it wouldn’t just be a nostalgic cameo — it could be a pivotal moment that connects Marvel’s old and new generations of heroes.
What’s Next for Marvel’s Avengers Saga
Marvel’s next two Avengers films are expected to redefine the superhero movie landscape. Avengers: Doomsday will reportedly set up the events of Secret Wars, potentially uniting (or dividing) heroes across timelines.
While nothing has been confirmed yet, fans are bracing for announcements about returning characters, potential crossovers, and maybe even long-awaited reunions — like the Spider-Men swinging back together one more time.
Until then, Garfield’s cryptic smile and cheeky answers will keep fans guessing.