Mistaken for "the Man from Toronto", a mysterious assassin with a talent for brutal interrogation, the clueless Teddy manages to intimidate Coughlin into giving up a code.
The cabin is raided by the FBI, who convinces Teddy to pose as the Man from Toronto to help capture would-be Venezuelan dictator Colonel Marin.
Much to Teddy's jealousy, an agent is assigned to accompany Lori and her friend Anne on a day of luxury in Washington, D.C., telling them the trip has been provided by Teddy's job.
Planning to complete the $2 million contract by maintaining the ruse that Teddy is Toronto, Randy informs his Handler, who sends another assassin, the Man from Miami.
Randy guides Teddy through interrogating the hostages; inadvertently cutting one of the men, Teddy vomits all over him and another hostage, who admits he is Green, and Randy kills Marin's guards.
But realized they were working on behalf of Marin, who plans to use the weapon to assassinate the President of Venezuela during a visit to D.C.
Teddy leaves the room while Randy cuts off Green's thumb, and they are attacked by the Man from Miami but manage to subdue him.
They return to D.C. to attend Lori's birthday dinner, where Randy finds himself connecting with Anne.
Miami steals the thumb, which he and the Handler deliver to Marin. Teddy and Randy crash the deal, and the FBI arrives; Randy flees with the $2 million, while Miami and the Handler escape.
Taking the car, Teddy reconciles with Lori at the train station but parks on the tracks, and the car is destroyed by a train.
A year later, Randy has followed through on his dream of opening his own restaurant, and is in a relationship with Anne.
Teddy declares Randy his partner in his new online gym, presenting him with a small payment toward replacing Debora, but Randy later calls Teddy during a livestream workout to threaten him.